By James Heinz
In a previous article https://wmhs.org/a-great-lakes-freighter-survives/ I wrote about the Canadian bulk carrier MICHIPICOTEN suffering a mysterious spontaneous hull fracture in Lake Superior on June 8, 2024, that led to the ship taking on water and assuming a 15 degree list to starboard. Now we know why.
Recently I attended a lecture by U.S. Coast Guard Commander Joseph Burgess at the annual meeting of the Great Lakes chapter of the Society of Naval Architects and Marine Engineers (SNAME) who explained to us why the MICHIPICOTEN cracked like an eggshell.
Just about anything that could be done wrong was done wrong.

In November 2021 the ship suffered a grounding that resulted in 115 feet of the hull buckling inwards. In 2024 a survey found that many of the plates had suffered “wastage”, which means that due to corrosion they were 24% thinner than when the ship was built in 1952.

In 2024 new loading software was installed which calculated the maximum “bending moment” for the ship in harbor and out at sea. The crew said that the new software did not calculate the ship’s load accurately and did not use it. It was later found that they did not know how to use it. The company did not have a policy on how much “bending moment” was permissible. Five times in 2024 the ship was overloaded to as much as 112% of the maximum at sea bending moment.

The ship was incorrectly loaded with 600 tons dumped into hold #4 that was supposed to go into two other holds. The first mate delegated the loading duties to the 2nd mate even though the 2nd mate was not supposed to load the ship. The captain was aware of the mistaken loading but did not correct it. The captain also did not comply with company loading policy. The crew did not trim the cargo before departing.
Finally, an unrecorded and unexplained cement patch was found on frame #92.
All of these events occurred near or on frame 92, which had a 13 foot crack a half inch to an inch wide in that “also extended 55 inches into the inboard longitudinal bulkhead of the #4 ballast tank, and that the #1 inner void was compromised as well”.
MICHIPICOTEN was Canadian registered and in Canada cargo vessels are not inspected by the government but by the classification, or insurance, agencies, one of which certified the ship to sail. No criminal wrongdoing was found and the case was referred to Transport Canada for possible civil disciplinary action. All photos are from Reddit r/GreatLakesShipping.
All this information is from Commander Burgess’ report and the U.S. Coast Guard report, which is available online. The U.S. Coast Guard investigated the incident since it occurred in U.S. waters. As of the date of this story, MICHIPICOTEN is laid up at the Fraser Shipyard in Superior, Wis.
———————–
James Heinz is the Wisconsin Marine Historical Society’s acquisitions director. He became interested in maritime history as a kid watching Jacques Cousteau’s adventures on TV. He was a Great Lakes wreck diver until three episodes of the bends forced him to retire from diving. He was a University of Wisconsin – Milwaukee police officer for thirty years. He regularly flies either a Cessna 152 or 172.

